Dance in Islamic Culture: Between Piety, Mysticism, and Self-Expression

Introduction: A Complex Consensus in Diversity

Dance in Islamic culture is a complex and ambiguous phenomenon that cannot be evaluated uniformly. Its attitude is formed in the triangle of religious prescriptions (sharia), Sufi mystical practice, and local folk traditions. As a result, a wide range of practices emerges: from complete rejection in some Salafist circles to the elevation of dance to the highest form of worship among Sufis. This contradiction is rooted in different interpretations of Islamic law and anthropology, as well as in the historical interaction of Islam with pre-Islamic cultures of the conquered peoples.

Religious-Legal (Fikh) Discourse: Permissibility and Conditions

Within Islamic law (fikh), there is no direct prohibition on dance in the Quran. However, scholars derive their evaluations from general principles and hadiths (narrations of the Prophet Muhammad's words and deeds).

Critical Approach (Makruh or Haram): Based on hadiths that condemn imitation of the opposite sex, excessive mixing of genders, and entertainments that distract from remembering Allah (zikr). Particularly condemned are dances that are considered to provoke sexual excitement (fitna), whether performed by women in front of men or vice versa. In this sense, many modern pop dances are often criticized.

Moderate/Permitting Approach (Mubah or Halal): Allows dancing under certain conditions:

Intention (尼亚т): Dance should not be sinful or idle, but may serve permissible joy (e.g., at a wedding).

Content: Movements should not imitate the opposite sex or be indecent.

Context: Absence of mixing genders, consumption of haram (alcohol), musical instruments that may be considered forbidden.

Clothing: Should comply with Sharia norms (awrat covered).

As a result, different customs have formed in various madhabs (legal schools) and cultures. For example, at weddings in Arab countries, dancing is often done separately, while in the Caucasus or Turkey, mixed dances at family celebrations may be the norm.

Sufism: Dance as a Path to God

The most developed and sacralized form of dance was created by Sufism — a mystical direction in Islam. Here, dance (often called sama', meaning "listening") becomes a spiritual practice.

Whirling Dervishes (Mevlevi Tariqa): Founded by the great Persian poet and mystic Jalal ad-Din Rumi (13th century). According to legend, he began to whirl, raising his hands, after hearing the sound of hammers from goldsmiths, entering a state of mystical ecstasy. The ritual of "sema" is not just a dance but a complex liturgical act.

Symbols: The white skirt (tennure) — the shroud of the ego, the tall hat (sikke) — the gravestone of the ego. The shedding of the black cloak symbolizes the liberation from the world. The whirling against the clock and around the hall's circumference reflects the universe's rotation around its Creator, the unity with the cosmic order. The right hand raised to the sky (for receiving divine grace), the left hand lowered to the earth (for conveying it to the world).

Goal: Through rhythmic circling, repetition of Allah's name (zikr), and special music, the dervish strives to achieve the state of fana' — the dissolution of the individual "I" into God.

Zikr with Movements in Other Tariqas: Many Sufi brotherhoods (e.g., Qadiriyya, Naqshbandiya, Chishtiyya) use rhythmic swaying, tilting of the head or entire body, clapping in their practice, which, strictly speaking, are not dance in the artistic sense but represent a physical form of worship that helps to concentrate and raise spiritual energy.

Folk and Ethnic Dances: Cultural Heritage

In addition to the religious context, there is an enormous variety of secular and semi-religious dances in the Muslim world, rooted in pre-Islamic times and reflecting national identity.

Middle East and the Arab World:

Abdominal Dance (Arabic. Raqs Sharqi — "Eastern Dance"): Developed in the Ottoman Empire. Initially, it was a solo female dance performed at women's gatherings. In the 19th–20th centuries, it was commercialized and performed in restaurants. Among Muslim theologians, the attitude to it is predominantly negative due to its openness and eroticization, although it remains part of the cultural code in secular society.

Dabka: A collective, energetic dance-dance, widespread in the Levant (Palestine, Lebanon, Syria, Jordan). Performed at weddings and celebrations, symbolizing unity and joy.

Iran and Central Asia:

In Iran, there are elegant, smooth folk dances where attention is paid to hand, head, and facial movements. After the Islamic Revolution of 1979, public dances (especially solo female) were actually banned as contrary to public morality, but they have been preserved in the private lives of the diaspora.

In Uzbekistan, Tajikistan — bright, fiery dances with characteristic movements of shoulders, hands (e.g., "Lazgi").

Caucasus:

Lazinka: An energetic, virtuosic pair dance of Caucasian peoples. Demonstrates agility, pride, respect. Although often performed at Muslim weddings, it has pre-Islamic origins.

South and Southeast Asia:

In Indonesia and Malaysia, Islam coexists with rich local dance traditions (e.g., dances of the island of Java), which often have narrative or ritual character and are not considered contrary to religion in their traditional form.

Modern Challenges and Trends

Globalization and Pop Culture: Youth in Muslim countries actively consume and create modern dance forms (hip-hop, contemporary), which raises new questions about their permissibility from an Islamic perspective.

Dance as Protest: In such countries as Iran, dances posted on social networks have become an act of civil disobedience and a struggle for personal freedom.

Rise of Conservatism: In some regions, under the influence of Salafist ideas, traditional folk dances are being replaced as "innovations" (bid'a) or "pagan remnants".

Conclusion: Continuous Dialogue and Reinterpretation

Dance in Islamic culture is not a static category, but a field of continuous negotiations between text, tradition, and living practice. Its status fluctuates from the sin of "Satan's amusement" to the peak of mystical knowledge.

Sufi sama' proves that within Islam, it is possible to elevate physical practice to the level of high theology, where movement becomes prayer. Folk dances demonstrate the remarkable vitality of pre-Islamic cultural layers adapted to the Islamic context. And modern debates reflect the dynamics of the search for Muslim identity in the global world.

Thus, Islamic culture does not negate dance per se, but always puts it within certain meanings and boundaries. Its development continues, and the future of dance in Islam will depend on how Muslim communities respond to the challenges of modernity, managing to maintain a balance between fidelity to tradition, mystical search, and the natural human need for rhythmic, meaningful movement.

Permanent link to this publication: